Blazalek.com

Founders.pl · Episode 2 ·

What is a newsletter worth when search traffic falls?

For the English dub, select Settings → Audio track → English (US).

Episode summary

When shoppers ask AI for a product recommendation, how can a store catch their attention? Wojtek Blazalek tells Wiktor Cyrny how a newsletter can bring customers back. A regular reader might welcome a new offer. A former subscriber might pay a small fee to keep their data. To set a sending schedule, separate people who still read your emails from those who stopped responding months ago.

Sending to inactive subscribers can damage sender reputation. Wojtek explains how one company used separate sending infrastructure to protect email deliverability for its engaged subscribers. Before shifting an email budget to ads, he suggests checking the requirements from Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft and asking when you stop emailing inactive subscribers. For the email itself, AI can build an HTML template around a brand’s logo and colours, but he recommends writing the first draft of the email yourself.

Host
Wiktor Cyrny
Guest
Wojtek Blazalek
Publisher
Founders.pl

Chapters

  1. 0:20 How does AI search change the role of email?
  2. 2:40 What changes when AI summarises the inbox?
  3. 5:11 How often should you email each part of your list?
  4. 10:57 How do you make the case for an email budget?
  5. 15:59 Where can AI help when creating an email?

Transcript translated from Polish

Edited for readability. Select a timestamp to hear the corresponding passage. Original auto-generated Polish captions (TXT)

  1. 0:00

    Wiktor Cyrny Wiktor Cyrny here. Welcome to the Founders studio. With us today is Wojtek Blazalek, a leading expert in email deliverability. In a nutshell, his work is about making sure your emails get where you want them to go and get the response you’re hoping for.

  2. 0:20

    Wiktor Cyrny I’d like to start this episode with something that’s happening in the market. I’m talking about AI, which at times we can hardly imagine living without. AI has also shifted some of the traditional traffic away from search engines and SEO, as people turn to AI to look for products. When we talked before the recording, you mentioned that we’re seeing something of an email renaissance. We can use email to reach potential customers with the product or service we have to offer. What does that actually look like, and how does AI affect email deliverability?

  3. 1:04

    Wojtek Blazalek That’s my theory. We can see it quite clearly, and we now have hard data showing that traffic from search engines to websites has fallen by about a third in Poland. As far as I know, the figures are even higher in the United States, and that trend is going to continue. A lot of businesses are built on this assumption, this business model: we attract people to our website and then some of them become customers. But once we know that traffic is going to keep falling, that turns those models upside down.

  4. 1:43

    Wojtek Blazalek My view is that email is going to come back into favor in a bigger way. It’ll be one of the last channels we have for reminding customers we’re here in a way that’s quite different from anything these AI tools let us do. There’s a paradox in that. Email was one of the first technologies to emerge from the internet revolution, if you like. The protocol, this form of communication, is more than 50 years old. Yet today it may be gaining in importance because the market is changing, and the way we acquire or retain customers is changing with it. So when it comes to AI, or perhaps more specifically AI search, email may be the one thing we can still rely on to remind customers we exist.

  5. 2:40

    Wiktor Cyrny One other thought about AI. We’re using agents more and more, for instance to summarize our emails. That could mean the person receiving our email skips the very thing we want them to click. How do we deal with something like that?

  6. 3:03

    Wojtek Blazalek I think that’s very difficult. My instinct would be to think in terms of building a brand, and not necessarily just in terms of the performance measures we’ve been looking at until now: people clicking links or opening our emails. If we’re talking about summaries, I think more and more people are going to use agents to tell them what’s new in their inbox today. What we should focus on is getting that agent to mention us as something the person might actually be interested in. Say an online shop has sent me an offer for something. Can that offer be one of the things the agent mentions in its inbox summary?

  7. 3:49

    Wojtek Blazalek Right now, what AI in the inbox does most often is summarize a specific business conversation. Say there’s a thread of 30 replies with forwards, people on CC and so on. For that, it’s a great tool. But I have a feeling that in the future, people might also use it this way: ‘Tell me, what’s interesting today? Who’s written to me?’ That’s how we’ll have to think about it.

  8. 4:22

    Wojtek Blazalek Think about what happens with search. When I search, I’m expressing an intention: I want something, I’m looking for something, even if AI takes over the search. With email, I’m the sender and I’m already in the inbox. Now I’m trying to get through to my customer, the consumer, and catch their attention. We’re starting from a completely different position. My theory, and I don’t know how well it will hold up, is that as search traffic falls further and further, email could be that last foothold for businesses and brands. It could be the place where it’s easier for them to communicate, get through and compete for their customers’ attention.

  9. 5:11

    Wiktor Cyrny Exactly. When we have a customer or a recipient on our mailing list, email gives us a way to reach out to them, to send them a newsletter they’ve agreed to receive. So there’s already some potential interest. But as I understand it, we can’t do that too often, or we might end up in spam, for instance. What can we do? What are some good practices to keep our messages from suffering the same fate as junk mail?

  10. 5:38

    Wojtek Blazalek As you mentioned, it’s primarily about frequency. If we send to the same address several times a day, we can hardly expect spectacular results. Quite the opposite. Put yourself in the recipient’s shoes. I’d find it irritating if I kept getting messages from the same brand too often. So it’s becoming absolutely essential to segment my list: people who are engaged, those who are less engaged, those who aren’t engaged at all, and those I should stop sending to because they haven’t responded in any way to what I send them.

  11. 6:21

    Wojtek Blazalek It’s worth putting together a different message for each of those segments. We’re talking about newsletters, which, in the broadest sense, are a kind of brochure a brand sends out from time to time. What we tell people depends on the product or service we offer. It might be a notice about new features in our product, or a new blog post. I think those things are still interesting. And if you look at ecommerce, for instance, various studies show that people are interested in discounts, promotions or a new offer. They actually expect to hear about them. In my view, those things will continue to interest people, but you need to be more precise and shape the message a little differently for each segment.

  12. 7:16

    Wojtek Blazalek What we say to people who interact with our brand regularly might be quite different from what we say to someone who rarely does. If someone rarely opens our emails and doesn’t visit the site much, and we have that information, it might be worth offering them a special discount. Or take a SaaS company that sells subscriptions. If a customer has left and canceled their subscription, we can put them in a segment where we try to win them back. We might offer a discount, or offer to keep their data on the platform for a small fee. Say I paid $20 for a subscription, used the tool for two years, but for various reasons I don’t want it any longer. I cancel. The company could email me and say, ‘Look, if the data you have with us is important to you, we can keep it for you for $5 a month, or $3 a month. Would you like to think about it?’

  13. 8:20

    Wiktor Cyrny This segmentation seems really important to me, because not everyone knows about it. So let’s recap. If I’m a business owner, or we’re a company that sends newsletters or communicates with customers in other ways, it’s worth organizing the people we reach into groups. We contact the most engaged people as well as those who are less engaged, but what we say to them needs to be different. Have I understood you correctly?

  14. 8:55

    Wojtek Blazalek A different message, and even different ways of sending it, so that…

  15. 8:58

    Wiktor Cyrny Oh, that’s interesting. Could you say more about that right now?

  16. 9:01

    Wojtek Blazalek I saw a really interesting example in a presentation. I forget the name of the company, but I think they sold houses. They had a lot of success grouping people by how active they were. They sent each of those groups a completely different message, with completely different creative, and they even used slightly different sending infrastructure. That’s because if we send a lot of mail to inactive users, our reputation can suffer. If we use a separate channel for each group, each channel has its own reputation. So the less active people don’t affect our ability to get mail through to the more active ones.

  17. 9:50

    Wojtek Blazalek They got really good results with that. I’m seeing a similar trend among my own clients. When we talk about it, they’re ready to go in that direction, and some of them are already taking the first steps. I’d really recommend it. I’ve seen plenty of examples where it works well.

  18. 10:10

    Wiktor Cyrny Let me bring in something from the first episode. I’d recommend watching that one too if you’re joining us for the first time in episode two. One of the things we discussed was reputation: it affects how a mailbox provider sees us, which in turn makes a big difference to email deliverability. So do take a look. And there’s the question of how to put that reputation right. Companies often start from a position where their reputation is already a little weak. Then we might end up in spam, or reach people who just aren’t interested in our newsletter, our emails, that kind of electronic communication.

  19. 10:57

    Wiktor Cyrny We’ve talked about AI. Now let’s turn to budgets, because these improvements cost money too. What if your boss says, ‘Email doesn’t work. Nobody’s opening our messages. It’s not worth putting money into this. Let’s spend it on Facebook ads instead’? Suppose someone watching us wants to tell their boss, ‘We could hire Wojtek Blazalek to repair our reputation and get those emails delivered.’ What could they say to their boss?

  20. 11:39

    Wojtek Blazalek I think it’s worth considering how long we’ve been using the same techniques in our email program. In my own experience, the situation you describe often applies to companies that have been doing the same thing for years. What may have worked back then could be out of date today. In some ways it used to be a little easier. There weren’t as many emails competing for space in each inbox. As we mentioned earlier, around 400 billion emails are sent across the world every day.

  21. 12:21

    Wiktor Cyrny And on top of that, AI is throwing a whole lot of these digital emails into the mix.

  22. 12:26

    Wojtek Blazalek Yes, though they’re included in that figure. The total is rising by about 4% a year. If we look back 10 years, we were using techniques that worked for us. We look at them today and they don’t work. That doesn’t mean the whole email channel is ineffective. What I’d advise is to rethink the approach. Check whether we meet the latest requirements from Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft. They announced new sending requirements together about two years ago. And take another look at the mailing list. Is it segmented? Are we phasing out mail to inactive customers?

  23. 13:10

    Wojtek Blazalek We used to take a ‘spray and pray’ approach. I think that misses the mark today. We need to make sure we stop sending further messages to people, to subscriber addresses, that haven’t been in touch with us for a long time. We should also pay attention to segmentation and to the content itself. I think it calls for a full review, because various studies, for instance from Statistics Poland or Eurostat, put the share of internet users who regularly check and send email at 70 to 87%. That’s a huge audience. I don’t know whether that many internet users are on Facebook, for example.

  24. 13:50

    Of course, everyone uses Google. That’s a given; nobody can imagine life without it now. But there’s a reason Google offers us email accounts. They made Gmail available. They must know something, and that tells you they see potential there. Gmail is one of the most popular mailbox providers in the world, and here in Poland it accounts for a large number of users too.

  25. 14:23

    Wojtek Blazalek Poland is actually a fairly unusual market. We have WP and we have Onet. Estimates vary, but that could be as much as 30 to 40% of the market. That’s a sizeable segment. Compare that with other markets: in the United States, between 70 and 80% goes to providers like Gmail, Yahoo and Microsoft. Poland is quite unusual in Europe, even worldwide. As far as I know, Germany and France are the only other countries that see comparable shares for local providers. In Germany it’s GMX and WEB.DE, and in France it’s Orange. In most places, you could say that Google is the dominant provider worldwide right now.

  26. 15:14

    Wiktor Cyrny I’d like to come back to that question of how to convince the boss. So, as I understand it, the idea is to show them the facts. Email can work in our favor. If our emails aren’t getting through or people aren’t reading them in the numbers we’d expect, perhaps the email itself hasn’t been put together properly. That’s worth looking into.

  27. 15:39

    Wojtek Blazalek Yes, that’s what I’d recommend. Before writing off the channel altogether, try a different approach. Just think about how long it’s been since the company changed anything in this area, and try looking at it afresh.

  28. 15:59

    Wiktor Cyrny We’ve talked about AI, and there’s another phenomenon that’s getting a lot of attention: AI slop. How does that show up in email? How can we deal with it, or how should we respond to it?

  29. 16:12

    Wojtek Blazalek I’ll speak from the perspective of people who send emails, because that’s my role. More and more newsletter tools of all kinds offer to generate content using AI. Most of the resulting content, let’s be honest, is slop. Yes, it makes it easier to put the email together and fill it with copy. But to the end user it’s completely worthless, and I’d strongly advise against doing that. Where I do think AI works really well is in creating HTML templates. It’s already very good at that. You can sit down with it, play around with it and get excellent results there.

  30. 16:56

    Wiktor Cyrny Could you explain? Let me interrupt you there. What do you mean?

  31. 16:59

    Wojtek Blazalek The creative, meaning what the email looks like. Say we’re sending a newsletter. AI gives us some useful possibilities. We can ask, ‘Make me an HTML email template. Here’s my logo. Here are my colors. Take a look at my website and pick up the styles.’ It can already do a very good job of that.

  32. 17:22

    Wojtek Blazalek But when it comes to the content itself, I really advise against having it generated. If you’re going to work with AI, I think the most important thing is to write that first draft yourself. Then ask it, ‘Could you improve the style?’ or ‘How can I make my message more effective?’ Or ask it to evaluate what you wrote. But I’d advise against using those generators, particularly the ones built into newsletter sending tools. Flooding users with that slop won’t get them to interact. Remember, we’re competing for their attention. Those first few seconds matter most if we want someone to read on. When the text is generic and sounds technical, as though a robot wrote it, the chances of that person giving it their time are slim.

  33. 18:20

    Wiktor Cyrny Right. I think we’ll stop here and leave it there for today, because in the next episode we’ll start with how to write a good email and how to write that opening sentence. I hope that encourages you to watch the next installment of our conversation with Wojtek Blazalek.

  34. 18:41

    Wiktor Cyrny I hope you’ll join us. See you then.